salt of the earth

Salt of the Earth

bar
5523 Penn Ave
MONDAY
05:00 PM - 11:00 PM
TUESDAY
05:00 PM - 11:00 PM
WEDNESDAY
05:00 PM - 11:00 PM
THURSDAY
05:00 PM - 12:00 AM
FRIDAY
05:00 PM - 12:00 AM
SATURDAY
05:00 PM - 12:00 AM
Reviews
Jessica Rosenberg - February 10, 2015

Note: I went with a group of people. One is a fellow Yelper, and I very much got the impression that he'd give SOTE a 4 if not 5. So take what I say with that grain of, well, salt... The menu was... difficult. (1) The menu was DIFFICULT TO READ--sitting on a large chalkboard on a corner of the room. (2) The menu was DIFFICULT TO DECODE--the menu items were pared down so greatly that you could have no concept of what a dish was actually like until you asked about it or ordered it. Further, sometimes the menu left off parts that were important to some of us, like the "hanger" (aka steak) be loaded with bacon. (3) The menu was DIFFICULT TO GET INSPIRED BY--each dish had something bleh sounding in it. (4) The menu was DIFFICULT TO WORK WITH--Can I get the hanger without the bacon? No. Can I get the halibut without the shellfish? No. So they do not seem to do substitutions. As a result, there was only one main dish on the entire list of six or seven dishes that I could eat, and it did not appeal to me. But that is what I got. And indeed I didn't love it. Tofu (pan fried very briefly, it seemed) with a dusting of something unrecognizable on top, on a bed of meh sauerkraut, with a few potatoes (simple and good), a few dollops of whole-grain mustard (standard stuff), and a few gherkins (severely out of place). Not one of the better meals I've eaten--just warm and dull with notes of sourness. I did taste a bit of the steak part of the bacon-filled hanger steak and thought it was incredible; too bad I don't eat bacon. I also tasted a small bite of the seitan and thought it was incredible, as well; too bad I didn't want to eat fried gluten. The appetizers were interesting--salmon with caviar on a bed of gelified celery, and then lamb and steak tartare with something crunchy/poppy in there. The desserts, like everything else here, were trying a little too hard. Gelified rhubarb, shaved cheese over bitter marmalade, etc. The drinks, again, like everything else here, were trying a little too hard. The atmosphere was okay. There are two floors--downstairs has big, bench-style tables (I never like these). Upstairs has private tables. We were a group of 7, and so were put upstairs where we indeed had privacy. For a while. Because soon another big group came in and they were sat next to us. Big groups are loud, so it felt lame to put the two groups in the same room and so affect our good time (their conversation drowning out ours). Especially because we were there for a celebration, and the other group looked to be there for the same. So overall, I just was not wowed. The whole thing was trying a bit hard and it felt like often the presentation was more important to SOTE than the taste or price, when most diners want good taste and price over presentation.

Maria Törnkvist - September 21, 2014

Best place in Pittsburgh for a modern and inventive dinner experience with a European touch. Really in the same league as most of the 1 Michelin Star restaurants in Europe. Good wines and knowledgable servers.

Scott smith - March 23, 2014

This is the most pretentious hipster hangout ever. The food was okay but nothing special and portions were meager. No Maker's Mark or Jameson's in the bar? Is there any respectable bar in the world that doesn't have those two? The paint job and exterior design looks like a sewage treatment plant. The menu on your smart phone, total bullshit. Wouldn't eat there again if it was free.

Jeanette Harris - June 30, 2014

One of my favorite restaurants in Pittsburgh. Always inventive and super delicious plates. An amazing bar with bartenders that really care about what they are doing and know their stuff! Always accommodating of gluten allergies!

Tom Murphy VII - June 13, 2012

Love this place. The food is awesome and there is always something suitable for vegetarians (~2 entrees). Cocktails are good enough to try; small but good beer list. Not really that expensive. Service staff is very knowledgeable. Everybody here really cares about food and drink. The communal seating might be weird for a date but it works better than you'd think with most parties. Often busy, so either show at an unusual time or be prepared to wait a bit.

Nearby Listings
Coca Cafe'
3811 Butler St
Cafe
08:00 AM - 09:00 PM
Dor-Stop Restaurant
1430 Potomac Ave
Restaurant
06:00 AM - 03:00 PM
Piacquadio's Restaurant & Lounge
300 Mt Lebanon Blvd
Night Club
11:00 AM - 11:00 PM
Giant Eagle
6320 Shakespeare Street
Restaurant
06:00 AM - 12:00 AM
House Of Hookah
1903 E Carson St
Night Club
05:00 PM - 03:00 AM
Casbah
229 S Highland Ave
Restaurant
11:30 AM - 02:30 PM
Casbah
229 S Highland Ave
Restaurant
05:00 PM - 11:00 PM
McDonald's
4557 Ohio River Blvd
Cafe
24 Hours
McDonald's
6361 Penn Ave
Cafe
Rumerz
1216 Woods Run Ave
Night Club
03:00 PM - 02:00 AM
Walnut Grill Fox Chapel
911 Freeport Rd
Restaurant
11:00 AM - 12:00 AM
Union Pig and Chicken
220 N Highland Ave
Bar
10:00 AM - 11:00 PM
Espresso A Mano
3623 Butler St
Cafe
07:00 AM - 09:00 PM
All Around Sound Productions
410 Lenox Ave
Night Club
McDonald's
11591 Frankstown Rd
Cafe
05:00 AM - 12:00 AM
House of Lee
8145 Ohio River Blvd
Night Club
11:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Rockefeller's Grille
1833 McKees Rocks Rd
Bar
11:00 AM - 11:00 PM
Eleven
1150 Smallman St
Restaurant
11:30 AM - 11:00 PM
Salt of the Earth
5523 Penn Ave
Bar
05:00 PM - 12:00 AM
New Great Valley Lanes
1501 Highwood Ave
Night Club
09:00 AM - 02:00 AM
mobile fallback
desktop fallback