Shoemakers American Grille
Reviews
Very expensive, but I felt I got my money's worth. Request ahead as they will be willing to provide quieter seating. Its worth coming at an odd time (5pm or earlier) on an odd day as there are far fewer people--the privacy pushed it to the next level. Great for our second anniversary. Price keeps it from a higher rating ($107 for two).
Best steak I have ever had. Nice atmosphere and good service.
Best restaurant in Lynchburg! Always a good experience.
Expensive, but probably the best/finest restaurant in town. You don't need to dress up, but you might feel a little out of place. The food is top notch for a city this size. You can't go wrong with anything on the menu. You might not like the place if you don't like fusion or have an adventurous palate.
Apparently they have stepped their game up. My wife and i went for our anniversary recently and it was amazing. I had the crabcake and steak and both were perfect. The crabcake wasn't overbreaded. My wife got salmon stuffed with crab and it was also very good. The salmon was not overly fishy. The appetizer and desert was also very good. Our server was very friendly and knowledgeable. He even brought us a free cup of the soup of the day. By far one of the best restaurants in lynchburg.
