Poor food quality. The tomatoes were hard as a rock and the lettuce was completely white with no taste and no redeeming food quality. The wait staff is idiotic and unhelpful. We've been in the Keys for 20 years. Every few years we try this place again hoping for improvement. Never any improvement!!! Won't be back. For dining in the upper Keys, would recommend (no particular order): Marker 88; Snook's; The Buzzard's Roost; Snappers Waterfront Saloon; Mrs. Mac's Kitchen.

Went with friends and everything each one of us had was phenomenal! The service was excellent. The sunset view can’t be beat. And when you’re done, you can stop by the tiki bar for a specialty drink and listen to some live music. I have to add a note about the pizza. I’m really tired of places advertising “real authentic New York pizza” when the vast majority don’t have a clue! Having said that, I saw just such an advertisement on the menu and I decided to give this place a shot…WOW! I was so impressed that I had to meet the person making the pies. Apparently the pizza menu here is a relatively new thing, and Martin, the only chef that makes the pizzas, spent many years in Brooklyn and NYC working for “certain” families… and he has it down! You know – the kind of pizza with the right blend of garlic and seasoning, the crust is light and just crispy on the outside and fluffy on the inside, and the oil from the peperoni and the molten liquid cheese would run of the side if you didn’t pic it up and fold it (like you are supposed to!) Thank you Martin for bringing back some memories!

Food was just OK, Burger & Salad were terrible. The torture was the lack of service. I let the manager know that twice I was forced to go looking for our waitress to get service for our family and I believe we were her only table. When I finally was able to find the waitress to get us drinks she showed up at the table giving my daughter the "whatever look".

I have passed this place many times and decided this past weekend to give it a try with a few friends on our way to Marathon. Nice water view but the food and service was worse than bad- Two of us had the Hogfish sandwich and the bun was cold ( just pulled out of bag) and the filet of fish covered the bun only half way, A joke for a sandwich. The wait stff was busy eating at the bar with it looked to be their friends and I had to wipe the sticky bar top off my self. When the waiter asked " How was your meal" I stated that the they were very skimpy on the fish and he said" I know, I would tell them but it doesnt do any good" TWO THUMBS DOWN. There are great resturants just down the road.

Not bad. Decent experience. Staff was cool And accomadating. January 2015.