Cash only, be prepared, no credit cards accepted here. Had 9 in our group, 4 teens and 5 adults. Most eating establishments in Tupper Lake shut down early, so I had asked a local resident where we could go and they told us Little Italy was probably the only place, but they wouldn't recommend it as they've had one too many bad experiences there. Our options were limited, so we took a chance. It is nice looking outside and inside. We arrived at 9PM, place closes at 10PM, we were seated quickly. Not too busy in there, maybe a half dozen people at the bar and another 4-5 table with customers. Ample staff on hand both in the open kitchen as it is a pizzeria as well as wait staff. We placed simple orders from the menu, nothing complex. Service was slow, the food was brought out in waves to different people in our group. It had to be a solid 30 minutes from when the first person was given their dish to when the last person got their's and that doesn't include one adult whose order they forgot to place, but didn't admit it, so she had to get her food to go. We were hungry and it got awkward as we waited at first, but the first people served were done eating by the time the last couple people got their dishes. Salads came out last. One person who was served first ordered angel hair pasta, but was given linguine. She asked to have he order corrected, the one waitress took the dish away, went in the back, then came back out with the original dish and told us the manager said it would take too long to make the angel hair dish so she'd have to eat what was given. She did reluctantly as she was hungry. The kids asked for the wifi password multiple times before being given to them, and the staff spelled the password wrong anyway. The waitress spelled it "pizzareia" on the paper, but it was "pizzeria" which the kids figured out and knew how to spell on their own. In the end, the food was pretty good, the prices reasonable, but the service, delivery of product, the wrong dish situation, and the forgotten order that was essentially brought with the check makes for an unacceptable experience. We should have listened to the local and just went to the fast food restaurant in town.

Slow service, no kids menu and they messed up our oder but the food was good and it's got a nice atmosphere

Great food, service and atmosphere! Prices are good too.

Great food and awesome service! 10stars

Awesome food, great service, good prices