TERRIBLE!!!! Do not order any burgers or pizza from this establishment! In my group, a Pizza, Elk Burger, Bison Burger and regular hamburger was ordered. The pizza tastes like overly-seasoned sause smothered in stale cheese and hard crust. The bison burger has no seasoning and hamburger has ZERO seasoning. The Elk burger was mine, and for $15, I was given a burger that was cold in the middle. The waitress told me that all burgers were cooked medium rare, BS-that is cold in the middle!!!! Also, for children, the "bear-pizza" which is a pizza that is supposed to look like a bear... Might as well been a Pizza from the frozen section of Wal-Mart. To top it all off, I told the waitress that I didn't want the Elk burger anymore because it made me almost throw up from having cold red meat in my mouth, and she still charged us for it. Reason was: I could have had the cook grill it longer... So, in other words, something that has already touched my mouth would have gone back on the grill that also cooks other peoples food? That sounds real sanitary... Note to the manager: I was furious that your waitress still charged my friend for this meal, but I didn't say anything because he was paying for my family's meal. For the cost of that meal, you're real lucky I didn't have a chat with you. You can keep you raw unflavored Elk Burger and enjoy your future unhappy customers.

It was pretty expensive for the amount of food but it was surely great. I would definitely go here again.

My husband and I visited the Slippery Otter after a long day in the park. We were seated immediately. Service was excellent! Our server stopped by the table just the right number of times and was very friendly and helpful. Beer selection is excellent. We had the pizza. Definitely give it a try! You won't be disappointed!

I read the other reviews and was a little surprised at how the pizza was raved. I thought it was good but not great (admittedly, I prefer deep crust). The craft beers were great and the service was very friendly.

Spending one night in Yellowstone my wife picked this place... At first we were skeptical as no one came to our table for about ten minutes but it turned out to be a misunderstanding and after that the service and food was out of this world thanks to our phenomenal server JAYR! We live in California and this is the best pizza we've ever had! If we ever come back this will be our first stop