I see most of the reviews are rather old ,2-3 yrs. I can say I have been patronizing this establishment since it opened. I have seen variations in service but never the food. It has always been consistently good. Since it reopened under the most recent management I have have seen some improvements, notably an excellent improvement in the draft beer choices. That will not be important to most area residents, but I consider it important to a person who will drive many miles out of Rockmart for a good meal . The service has always been good here because I try to treat the servers well, so I am paid back in kind. I only have one little annoyance to convey. Please leave salt and pepper on the table so I don't have to hunt down some from another table.

Similar, but not quite authentic New York pizza. Good but not great.

I used to love this place. I'm not sure if management has changed or what but the quality and service went from a high 8 to a 2.5 at best. This was my last time after paying almost 7.00 more for what they had on advertised special.

2 separate trips. 1st trip with the in laws we called in our order and advised them we had a $2 coupon from the box from a previous trip. She totaled the ticket on the phone and we went to pick up the pizza. We arrived at the location 25 minutes after the call (we were told 20 minutes) and when we wen to pay realized we lost the $2 coupon. The server at the register stated that she cannot honor the coupon as her manger will take it out of her pay. My father in-law who was paying just looked stunned that they were that cheap. I realize we sound cheap but we had also been there plenty of times and collected those coupons. So we went ahead and paid and waited another 20 minutes for our food...At that moment I said I will never eat here again. Well........Ahead 2 years wife and I are home and its getting late she says want some pizza I say sure. We live in a tiny town so not many choices. I say lets give Johnny's a try again we can order Stromboli. So we call.... Server says Johnny's Rockmart. I state we want to place an order for pickup. She requests my number and I tell her. She says that not in our system. Okay I said I can give you my info again. She says oh it this your first time calling with this number , I explained, Yes. "Oh, is there anyway you can pay for your order before you arrive?" What? No we are paying with cash... "Oh then we can't cook the food until you arrive and pay for it!" Really pay for food I have not received and that is not being delivered? Nutz! Long Story short I told the F&%k it and hung up. Seriously bad service and from the looks of it Money is a really really big issue here. She could have just called back later and verified the number... Customer is job......#995 get the money then we can cook.......Those sorry unhappy customers, who do we think we are?

Prices are a little high. My chicken parmesan took an hour and ten minutes, my wife's calzone came out ten minutes later. The calzone was good, the chicken parmesan was fast food quality with a LONG wait. While we were there the manager and waitress complained loudly about unhappy customers. I didn't see any happy customers. All the tables around us had similar experiences. Do you self a favor and don't eat here.