We absolutely loved this place!! We happened to be in town for a wedding, and came across this restaurant for lunch. It has an incredibly eclectic vibe, and was some of the best pizza we've ever had. But I think what put it over the top for us, was our waiter. Our young daughter has severe, life-threatening food allergies. Our waiter made absolutely sure that our daughter didn't get exposed to any allergens. (He checked with the chef regarding the ingredients in her entree, and had our french fries-without parmesan, mixed in a separate bowl to avoid a dairy contamination. He also put in bold font on our ticket that she had a dairy allergy.) Its was this kind of extra attention, that sets this restaurant apart. Whenever we are back in Crested Butte, we will always come back here!!

I went there a 3 years ago and loved it. They have great pizza combinations and it was a secret getaway in Crested Butte. My better half went this holiday but I was unable to go. Even with the change in location, I heard the food was just as good as we had years ago. However, this review is really not about the food at all...I have to mention something else: The Stash was running a special on T-shirts -- buy a pizza and get a shirt for $10. My gal bought me a neat shirt, wrapped in plastic and marked as "Large". When she came back to Washington D.C. with this shirt, we were disappointed to find that the shirt was actually a medium, as marked on the tag, but was mis-labeled as "large" on the exterior packaging. With a simple phone call I talked to Taylor who took down my number and address and he passed my info on to Carson, the GM. A day later I got a phone call from Carson advising that he had put the shirt in the mail and appreciated our patronage. I never expected this level of service from such a remote place. I received the correct size shirt and am now the proud wearer of a Secret Stash shirt. Since we have a place in CB South, I can't wait to come back and thank them in person for a great Christmas gift. Thanks again Secret Stash and can't wait to enjoy some Stash food soon.

Dont go - service is AWFUL!!! We have stopped eating at the restuarant when we are town and now just do delivery. The pizza is still GOOD and delivery is usually less than 30 minutes. Then we do not have to deal with all the incompetence of the wait staff and my children begging for $20 bucks to play video games. OUTRAGEOUS!!! I miss the old location at the end of Elk.

Inconsistent, very highly priced. One night best pizza ever, literally next night $90 for three pizzas ALL very under cooked. For prices like that we all expect quality control of some sort. Who knows....

We went to eat here after reading the reviews. The service was horrendous and we walked out. We were seated and no one came to our table to take our order or even tell us that someone will be right there. Servers were passing by, walking around like we were not there. After 12 minutes of sitting at around we left and let the usher know why we are leaving. I do not care if this place has excellent food. They lost us as an customer with their crappy service. Secret Stash...NOT...more like Secret Trash!! #FAIL#